Both conditions cause small, painful, recurrent ulcers that heal within one to two weeks without scarring, so the site is the single most useful discriminator. Recurrent intraoral herpes arises from reactivation of herpes simplex virus type 1 in the trigeminal ganglion and appears as a cluster of tiny vesicles that rupture into coalescing ulcers on keratinised, bone-bound mucosa, the hard palate and the attached gingiva, often on one side and sometimes after dental treatment or trauma. Minor recurrent aphthous stomatitis, by contrast, is not infectious, does not start as vesicles, and favours the non-keratinised, movable mucosa of the lips, cheeks, floor of mouth and ventral tongue, which makes option A a feature of aphthae rather than herpes. Option C, a yellow-grey fibrinous base with an erythematous halo, is the classic description of an aphthous ulcer, although herpetic ulcers can look similar once the vesicles have broken. Option D applies to both conditions in their minor forms, so it does not separate them; only major aphthae scar. Exam tip: keratinised mucosa with a vesicular start means herpes, non-keratinised mucosa without vesicles means aphthae, and primary herpetic gingivostomatitis is the one herpetic presentation that affects both.